(Reuters): Google is making one final effort to challenge a $2.6 billion EU antitrust fine.
Tuesday, Alphabet’s (GOOGL.O) Google launched a last-ditch attempt at Europe’s top court to reverse a 2.42 billion euro ($2.6 billion) EU antitrust penalties levied for market abuse relating to its shopping business, arguing that regulators had not demonstrated that its activities were anti-competitive.
After the General Court dismissed Google’s appeal of the penalty imposed by EU antitrust chief Margrethe Vestager in 2017 in 2021, the company resorted to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).
It was the first of three anti-competitive behavior fines that cost Google a total of 8.25 billion euros over the past ten years.
Thomas Graf, a lawyer for Google, claimed that the European Commission had failed to demonstrate that the firm’s treatment of competitors differently was abusive and that such treatment alone was not anti-competitive.
Companies don’t engage in competition by treating rivals fairly. By treating them differently, they compete. The entire purpose of competition is for a business to set itself apart from competitors. Not to unite with competitors in order to homogenize everyone, he warned the 15 judges.
“Qualifying every different treatment as abusive would harm competition, especially when it comes to the differing treatment of first- and third-party enterprises. The ability and incentives of businesses to compete and innovate would be compromised, according to Graf.
Attorney for the Commission Fernando Castillo de la Torre rejected Google’s claims, claiming the corporation had violated EU antitrust regulations by using its algorithms to unfairly favor its price comparison shopping service.
According to him, “Google was within its rights to apply algorithms that reduce the visibility of some results that were less relevant for a user query.”
In his words, “What Google was not entitled to do was to use its dominance in general search to extend its position over comparison shopping by promoting results of its own services, embellishing them with attractive features, and apply algorithms that are prone to pushing down the results of rivals and showing those results without attractive features.”
In the upcoming months, the CJEU will issue a ruling.
The current EU antitrust investigation into Google’s rich digital advertising business, where regulators threatened to split up the corporation in June, dwarfs this case and two others regarding the Android mobile operating system and the AdSense advertising service.
Google and Alphabet v. Commission (Google Shopping) is the case number C-48/22 P.
($1 = 0.9353 euros)
